On podcasts, coaches say all the right things:
“Character matters.”
“We want hard workers.”
“We look for student-athletes who love the game.”
And none of that is wrong.
But behind closed doors—in the dugout, at staff meetings, and over postgame phone calls—coaches are asking different questions.
Especially the ones at under-the-radar D1 programs who are still building, still scrapping, and still trying to compete with limited resources.
Here’s what they’re really asking when your son’s name comes across their desk—and what most families don’t realize matters.
1. “Can we actually get this kid?”
Before they evaluate talent, they evaluate recruiting reality.
Under-the-radar coaches don’t want to chase players who are just fishing for attention or stacking offers for leverage. They want kids who are gettable, committed, and actually interested.
That’s why emails that say “you’re one of my top choices” go further than “just keeping my options open.”
If a coach doesn’t believe your son would actually commit, they’re not wasting time. Period.
2. “Is he more polished—or more coachable?”
They’re not always looking for the most game-ready guy.
Sometimes, they’re looking for the most coachable blank canvas.
Overlooked D1 coaches often take pride in development. They know they won’t get the top 100 player—but they’re okay with the kid who’s raw, hungry, and doesn’t act like he knows everything.
Behind closed doors, they ask: “Is this someone we can mold—or will we spend two years un-teaching bad habits?”
3. “Will this kid actually show up and compete—or transfer after a year?”
With the transfer portal booming, this is a real fear.
Coaches at smaller programs are thinking long-term:
“If we invest in this guy, will he stick around—or leave the second he has a good season?”
That’s why loyalty, maturity, and intent matter more than ever.
If your son makes it clear he wants to build something, not just use a school as a stepping stone, he’s already ahead.
4. “Does he act like a guy we want to be around for 4 years?”
This one doesn’t show up on highlight videos.
Coaches talk to trusted scouts, tournament directors, and sometimes even opponents.
They want to know:
- How does he treat his teammates?
- Does he pout when he struggles?
- Is he coachable, humble, and consistent?
Culture fit is everything at overlooked D1s. They don’t have time for drama—they need guys who make the program better, not harder to manage.
5. “Why hasn’t this kid been picked up yet?”
This isn’t always asked with skepticism—sometimes it’s curiosity.
But if your son is still unsigned and clearly talented, coaches want context.
Is he late to the process? Underexposed? Just missed on early?
The more clearly you tell that story—especially in follow-up emails or coach conversations—the easier it is for coaches to move past the “what’s wrong with this guy?” question and lean into the “he’s just the kind of kid we love to develop.”
💡 Final Thought: Coaches Don’t Always Say It, But They’re Always Thinking It
The best way to earn trust from these overlooked D1 programs is to communicate like someone who actually understands what they’re up against.
- Show you’ve done your homework
- Show your son is reachable, coachable, and committed
- Show you’re not just chasing the biggest logo—you’re looking for the right fit
Because that’s exactly what they’re looking for, too.
#CollegeBaseball #PremierAthletes #RecruitingWithAlex #GetRecruited #D1Baseball #UnderTheRadar #BaseballRecruiting #HiddenGems #ParentsOfAthletes #InsideRecruiting #CollegeCoachTruths
